Add to that an ice cream that seemed to melt much too fast for easy enjoyment, I'd give this brand a pass. 9. Edy's Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Whether you call it Edy's or know it better as Dreyer's ...

Plain as it is, vanilla is the nation's favorite ice-cream flavor. Our expert tasters ... Turkey Hill and Dreyer's/Edy's are the least expensive, at 33 to 35 cents per half-cup serving; Steve's ...